Agree. The muffed kickoff return against Indy last year, the ball taken away from him in the Rams game, the fumble and two critical drops in the KC game... Those aren't just random plays; they're key moments when the team needed him and he choked. Yes, he had a clutch game against NE last year, and he has been reliable in the slot, but he's small, light, and not much of a runner after the catch, despite his speed. He's just another guy. I suspect Shakir is better.