Not to defend Bama's poor play in the Sugar Bowl, but they were missing 2 of their top 3 lineman (OT Andre Smith was suspended and OG Marlon Davis went out with injury on first drive). Then the coaching staff made a big mistake and put the 5 most talented lineman left out there, rather than putting kids who knew their positions. Therefore, Caldwell probably got overwhelmed by the adversity, lack of talent surrounding, and all the shifts Utah did didn't help either. Either way, losing 2 of your best linemen is a recipe for disaster against any top 10 team.