Jump to content

JuanGuzman

Community Member
  • Posts

    497
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by JuanGuzman

  1. just browsing the roster and man is it devoid of top notch stud players. Im my view the Bill's have three impact players:

     

    1. Aaron Schobel

    2. Lee Evans

    3. Jason Peters

     

    One could argue that Derrick Dockery and Donte Whitner are knocking on the door. If J.P Losman continues with last years strong play you could include him and maybe a rejuvenated Takeo Spikes. Donte Whitner probably will develope into one. Potentially Angelo Crowell & Ko-Simpson. I thought about adding Terrence McGee but he seems ill suited in the cover 2.

     

    Patriots impact players:

    1. Ty Warren

    2. Richard Seymour

    3. Vince Wilfork

    4. Tom Brady

    5. Asante Samuel

    6. Logan Mankins

    7. Adalius Thomas

     

     

    Potential Impact Players: Laurence Maroney, Benjamin Watson, Rosevelt Colvin, Dan Koppen, Ellis Hobbs and Matt Light (6). and Maybe 1 of their recievers developes as well.

     

    NY jets Impact Players:

    1. L. Coles

    2. Thomas Jones

    3. Kerry Rhodes

    4. Johnathan Vilma

    5. Shaun Ellis

    6. Nick Mangold

     

    Potential stars: D'brickshaw Ferguson, Justin Miller, Jericho Cotchery, Dewayne Robertson. Chad Pennington gets the job done.

     

    Miami Dolphin's Impact players:

     

    1. Jason Taylor

    2. Joey Porter

    3. Zach Thomas

    4. Chris Chambers

    5. Channing Crowder

     

    Potential: Vernon Carey, Ronnie Brown, Daunte Culpepper ( if he recovers), Marty Booker ( solid year last year maybe an abberation)

     

    I think i tried to fair in evaluating the divison and i could have missed some guys, or over rated some players. But it just seems to me the Roster lacks true studs who will have opposing coordinators altering their game plan. This years draft is crucial; the Bill's need to add some players who can have an impact right away and maybe a few more quality FA's in they expect to compete with the Patriots and Jets for the division title.

  2. Looks like we're going to sign Chris Brown today. Sirius NFL radio just said that his agent cancelled his scheduled visit in Detroit tomorrow and is still in Buffalo - probably working out the details of a contract.

     

    well hes prolly not coming here wanting to be a backup.

     

    That same reason could explain the cancellation in Detroit, they clearly gave up a lot for Tatum Bell and Kevin Jones is expected to be healthy at some point next season. Maybe he cancelled with Detroit because he doesn't want to be in a situation where there are 3 quality running backs again eg. Travis Henry and Lendale White in Tennessee. Obviously there is no link to the story but i guess it depends what they are emphasing as the meat to the story eg.: "(fact)Brown cancelled interview with Detroit therefore (hearsay) he must be signing with the bills. Vice Vesra: "(fact) Chris Brown stayed over an extra night in Buffalo to work on the details of a contract"

  3. In a negotiation you always have to consider your best alternative to a negotiated agreement (in the trade known as BATNA). In the Willis deal the BATNA (walk away position) is that he plays out his last contract year with us knowing he starts the season with a huge monkey on his back (very limited leverage as demonstrated by the fact that he was everyone's last choice this year...apparently including the BILLS!) and the Benjamins are going to follow the demand for him at the end of the year. I say hold for a good solid second round pick or even a very high first and if we don't get it...let him play. This is a no lose situation for us.

     

    good point that is the position i would like to see the Bill's take. But playing devil's advocate you could also factor in the (walk away position) might cause Willis to publicly demand for a trade (and we would get even less value) e.g D. Branch, Lance Briggs scenario or he would be such a locker room malcontent it would retard the development of the Bills young leaders eg. JP Losman, Lee Evans.

  4. yeah, thats fine, you can risk that pick in the 4th(?) when you have Clements and Troy Vincent on the team.

     

    i never said its impossible to convert players. but we are in no position to "experiment" at CB right now.

     

    strike that: Vincent wasnt on the team yet, but Winfield was. either way, the point stands.

     

    Yep, I am in agreement there. Nothing wrong with converting a player but you don't waste a top 20 pick on a gamble. I really like Laron Landry though and IMO he would be an upgrade over Ko-Simpson right now.... but you gotta draft based on need. And right now im comfortable with KO-Simpson as the starter for years to come.

  5. 2. The Jets trade for Thomas Jones -- Am I missing something here? I would have given New York kudos for acquiring the productive Jones from Chicago in exchange for its higher of two second-round picks (37th overall) straight up. But for the Jets to get themselves a 1,200-yard running back in the process of swapping second-round selections with the Bears (New York gets Chicago's No. 63 pick) registers as a steal in my book.
    Link

     

    Given what the Jet's had to give up (Pick # 37) for a running back Thomas Jones who had a far superior season with Bears and Chicago's 2nd round pick (63), I can't see the Bill's getting a deal for McGahee that would constitute anything near fair value.

  6. Jason Peters - 6'4" 328lbs 1/22/82

    Derrick Dockery - 6'6" 335lbs 9/7/80

    Melvin Fowler - not too much size at 6'3" 295lbs, but JP has to be able to see over SOMEONE. and he is the oldest at 3/31/79 (just about to turn 28)

    Langston Walker - 6'8" 345lbs 9/3/79

    Terrance Pennington - 6'7" 319lbs 9/25/83

     

    There is a definte theme to our O-line" Big Guys and supposedly quick feet. Given that generalization what style of running back would be best suited as the #1 back? Keep in mind that the options i give are based on style of play eg. Power Back, Scat Back or Balanced RB. Don't judge based on the talent of the players i use for options, rather assume that the players I list are all equal in terms of ability & only separated by style pf play - Power Back, Scat Back or Balanced RB.

     

    Power Back: One of those big power RB's in the mold of Jamaal Lewis, Deuce McAlister, Najeh Davenport and Brandon Jacobs, Reuben Droughns types. Won't make you miss to often but can flat out run right through you, would be tacklers frequently bounce off these guys, Not very good catching the ball out of the backfield, but much better at picking up the blitz. Potential FA's: T.J Duckett 6'0 254 Redskins. Potential Draft Pick: Tony Hunt 6'0 230 Penn State

     

     

    Scat Back: Smaller Back who relies more on bursts of speed, shifts direction easily (make you miss in a shoe box type player) won't break many tackles. Elite receiver out of the backfield, but struggles in pass protection. NFL Comparisons: Leon Washington, Warrick Dunn, Jerious Norwood, Tatum Bell. Potential FA's: Derrick Blaylock 5'9 210lbs NY JETS(?) couldn't really think of any other scat back FA's (Shaud Williams ahaha). Potential Draft Pick: Garret Wolfe Northern Illinois 5'7 177lbs

     

    Balanced Back:: Hybrid of the two - will break arm tackles and beat sloppy defenders on cuts. Won't bulldoze anybody nor juke you out of your shoes but a combination of some power, some speed, and some agility will help him breakruns. Multi-dimensional threat running and catching NFL prototypes: Ladell Betts, Thomas Jones, Chester Taylor, Micheal Pittman, Mike Bell, Chris Perry. Potential FA: Chris Brown Potential Draft Pick: Kenny Irons

     

    Some may not agree with my classifications of players, but mainly i just want to know what type of player would suit the Bill's O-line and coaching scheme. Fairchild is graduate of the Mike Martz offensive playbook one wonders if he would prefer a scat back in the mold of a Marshall Faulk. Although its worth noting the 2006 Bills were more of a power running team than the finnesse running games coordinated by Fairchild and Martz. The simple answer is to run a powerback behind a power o-line. Have a powerback who can physically wear down opposing teams and allowing Bill's O-line and RB them to assert their will on teams by the time the 4th Q rolls around. Lastly the balanced back breaks the occaisional strech play while keeping opposing defenses honest between the tackles, somewhat like McGahee last year when he had holes to run through.

     

    Obviously i ignored all world players who do it all like: L.T, Larry Johnson, Frank Gore, Clinton Portis, Steven Jackson.

  7. A source said Belichick believes he could motivate Moss to play and that he’d have the locker room support system to back him up, thanks to high-character veterans like Tom Brady, Richard Seymour and Rodney Harrison, among others. ... Word

    The writer lost his credibility when he mentioned Seymour and Harrison along with high-character in the same sentence.

     

    Harrison, a guy who takes cheap hits diving for peoples legs

    Seymour, the guy stamped on an NFL player in the game and quietly paid a big fine. Of course he escaped all the scrutiny that Haynesworth got for doing the same thing, because Seymour is a high-character guy :rolleyes:

     

     

    Harrison and Seymour are scum. Dirty players. When they can't win by talent, they take cheap shots. Pretty much somes up the Pats attitude as well after their elimination from the AFC championship in January.

     

    I think the writer certainly showed his colours by using the word "High-Character" but I do think strong-minded veterans like Harrison and Seymour who come to work to get the job done and put an emphasis on winning by any means would stop Randy Moss from being a cancer in the locker room, because he wouldn't instantly become a respected voice. He would first have to defer to those leaders mentioned and guys like Troy Brown.

  8. Official ESPN Link

     

    Does this mean Wes Welker won't see any of that money promised this year. Technically, the Pats don't have to negotiate a contract for Welker now and can let him play out his contract or sign him now more to their terms than the RFA offer. Welker is probably cursing the Dolphins for not letting him cash in that huge signing bonus in 7 days.

     

    I believe that Wes Welker's agent and the patriots already have the terms of a contract in place but it could significantly less than he would of got had they signed him to a rstricted FA offer sheet.

  9. League sources last night indicated Patriots coach Bill Belichick has long been enamored with Raiders wide receiver Randy Moss and would welcome the opportunity to bring him to Foxboro for the right price. Moss is on the block after two disappointing seasons in Oakland. The Raiders have worked on a deal that would send the mercurial wide receiver to Green Bay, with the Packers offering quarterback Aaron Rodgers and the Raiders holding out for a first-round pick, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. The Packers don’t seem in much of a rush to pull the trigger, however, which has left an opening for the Pats. A source said Belichick believes he could motivate Moss to play and that he’d have the locker room support system to back him up, thanks to high-character veterans like Tom Brady, Richard Seymour and Rodney Harrison, among others. ... Word out of Oakland is the 30-year-old wants to play on a contender before his career ends. The Raiders are intent on moving him following a miserable 2006 that saw him post career-worst numbers in receptions (42), yards (553), and touchdowns (three).
    Boston Herald

     

    Both ESPN and FOX SPORTS have picked up this rumour in their Rumour Central, and NFL News & Notes sections respectively. Although I tend to agree with Peter King's view:

    7. I think, first of all, there's almost no chance the Raiders will trade Randy Moss. But if they do, somehow, deal him, unless it's for some ridiculous bounty of picks and/or players, I will be first in line to rip the tar out of them. Here's why.

     

    When the Raiders dealt for Moss in 2005, they did so to give themselves the best downfield weapon in all of football ... the deep threat Al Davis had frothed to acquire for years. The Raiders didn't have the kind of quarterback who could consistently get him the ball. Kerry Collins in '05 gave way to Aaron Brooks last year, and it was laughable when Oakland people talked about Brooks last summer as though he were some sort of savior instead of the organization-killing kind of guy who just doesn't like football. (Ask anyone who's been around Brooks the last couple of years, in New Orleans and Oakland. The guy likes money, not football.) OK, so two straight frustrating seasons have left Moss unhappy. The Raiders aren't too thrilled with him either, and he turned 30 three weeks ago. But here sits Oakland now, with the first pick in the draft, and with a quarterback they're gradually coming to like a lot, JaMarcus Russell, in their sights. Russell can stand at the 20-yard line on a windless day, take one step, and fling a spiral into the end zone 80 yards away. Why on God's green earth would they ever consider trading the guy who could make such beautiful music with Russell over the next two or three years?

     

    There was a reason the Raiders traded for Moss, and that reason was to pair him with a quarterback with a great arm. Unless Moss has told Raiders brass, "I will not try if you keep me here'' (and I'm told he has not), it's foolish to entertain any offers for him. If Russell is playing by mid-October, Moss should have a 1,400-yard, 12-touchdown season

     

    Lastly with the Pat's addition of Wes Welker Chad Jackson (1st rd pick), Reche Caldwell and Jabar Gaffney its not as though WR is an extremely pressing need.

  10. I don't judge credibility based on typing skills. I am not going to call into question his character based on dropped charges, especially ones dropped due to lack of evidence. That usually means that there was no crime, either that or Marshawn is a criminal master-mind who managed to pull off the perfect crime. I hope all these questions about Lynch continue and snowball right up to the draft. Maybe he will be there in the second. Kind of like all that talk about Thurman from those GM's and scouts who thought it was a good idea to pass on him on draft day.
    Typing Skills would imply a typo, I think he just misspelt his name since he did it once in the topic title and once in the post. I don't mean to nitpick its just I think a lot of people just spend 1/2 hr day googling "top running back prospects" and immediately they're draft experts.

     

    Lynch is considered to be the second-best back in the draft, and unless he goes on a shooting spree during his team interviews that won't change. It's worth reiterating that Lynch was never arrested, but sometimes accusations -- unfairly -- can follow a guy through the whole draft process.
    AOL Sports Blog

     

    Read my post: Not once did I say i wouldn't draft him based on his character all i said was his stock could be falling due to the accusations + golf cart driving spree (which i thought was hillarious) GM and scouts inspect these prospects with a fine tooth comb and it doesn't take much to start a free fall.

     

    Terrible combine....he ran a 4.46...that is not terrible

     

     

    Get a CLUE . He looked damn good at the combine that I was watching.I do remember a back with a similar running style.Ahh I think his name was Eric Dickerson,ever heard of him??Eddie George,Larry Johnson are a couple more. Get a Clue boy.

     

    Players who dropped

     

    2. Marshawn Lynch, Cal, RB

     

    Another who came to Indy as his position's number two and faltered a little. This is the time of year when teams start poking holes in players and Lynch, who could be a splendid receiver at his position in the NFL, slipped a little because he trailed guys like Henry and Auburn's Kenny Irons in several categories.

     

    There is no question that Lynch may fit some team's west-coast offense, but he doesn't look like a Top 20 player today. His up-right running style is being criticized now, too.

    Combine Winners & Losers

     

    some of Lynch's combine results:

     

    Group 6 (RB) -- Top Five Results: 60 Shuttle

    1.Kenny Irons Auburn 11.47

    2. Chris Henry 11.51

    3. Briand Leonards 11.59

    4. Nate Ilaoa 11.78

    5. Marshawn Lynch 11.80

     

    Group 6 (RB) -- Top 10 Results: Three Cone

    1. Garrett Wolfe - 6.69

    2. Ahmad Bradshaw - 6.70

    3. Antonio Pittman - 6.84

    4. Brian Leonard - 6.88

    5. Chris Henry Arizona - 6.96

    6. Ramonce Taylor - 6.98

    7. Kenny Irons - 7.00

    8. Brandon Jackson - 7.00

    9. Marshawn Lynch - 7.05

    10. Jason Snelling - 7.06

     

    Group 6 (RB) -- Top Five Results: 20 Shuttle

    1. Garrett Wolfe - 4.08

    2. Ahmad Bradshaw - 4.09

    3. Chris Henry - 4.14

    4. Brandon Jackson - 4.14

    5. Antonio Pittman - 4.16

    N/A Marshawn Lynch

     

    Group 6 (RB) -- Top 10 Results: Vertical Jump

    1. Darius Walker - 40 1/2

    2. Adrian Peterson - 38 1/2

    3. Kenny Irons - 38

    4. Kolby Smith - 38

    5. Cory Anderson - 37

    6. Brandon Jackson - 37

    7. Thomas Clayton - 36 1/2

    8. Chris Henry - 36

    9. (tie) Marshawn Lynch - 35 1/2

    10. Eldra Buckley 35 1/2

     

    Group 6 (RB) -- Top 10 Results: Broad Jump

    1. Chris Henry - 10'7"

    2. Adrian Peterson - 10'7"

    3. Marshawn Lynch - 10'5"

    4. Ramonce Taylor - 10'5"

    5. Keny Irons - 10'3"

    6. Antonio Pittman - 10'3"

    7. Darius Walker - 10'3"

    8. Brandon Jackson - 10'2"

    9. Brian Leonard - 10'2"

    10. Lorenzo Booker - 10'1"

     

    Group 6 (RB) -- Top 10 Results: 40-Yard Dash

    1. Chris Henry - 4.40

    2. Adrian Peterson - 4.40

    3. Antonio Pittman - 4.40

    4. Kenny Irons - 4.45

    5. Lorenzo Booker 4.46

    6. Marshawn Lynch 4.46

    7. DeShawn Wynn 4.48

    8. Alonzo Coleman 4.49

    9. Ramonce Taylor 4.50

    10. Kolby Smith 4.51

    Combine Results

     

    The only event where he was near the top of his group was the the Broad Jump(3rd). The cone drills and shuttles which are vital for RB since they measure speed and agility coordination eg. how well you can cut Lynch was consistently in the the bottom tier of performers . Vertical was poor, his forty was middle of the pack. All im saying is if Lynch is supposed to be the consensus # 2 his combine results didn't show it, moreover his compettition K. Irons, C. Henry and A. Pittman consistently out performed him in drills.

     

    Lastly I think you guys are misinterpreting my original post: Not once did i say "don't draft Lynch he sucks". All I said was 12 is too high for him IMO. I went on to say I like his age, durability & recieving skills & he would be a steal if he somehow fell to (43) moreover i added maybe the bills could trade up to the late 1st round to get him.I agree with you guys that if his draft stock started plummeting it would be a good thing becuase he is the #2 RB IMO and it would increase the bill's chances of getting him. Please read the entire scope of a post before you get your panties in a knot. My post was neither a whole hearted endorsement of Marshawn's skill nor a complete dismissal of Lynch's ability to become an elite back in this league. i think it was a balanced assesment of an intriguing prospect. Also look up the word perceived in a dictionary.

  11. (12) DT Amobi Okoye 6'2 287 (Louisville)

    (43) CB Marcus McCauley 6'1 200 (Fresno State)

    (74) RB Tony Hunt 6'0 230 (Penn State)

    (107) WR Syvelle Newton 6'2 217 (South Carolina)

    (169) ILB H.B Blades 5'11 237 (Pitt) this one is wishful thinking, i'd like to see us move up to get 4th-5th round pick and snag him. Good chance all the others will be their when we draft IMO.

  12. It would sure be nice for JP's development and free Lee Evan's from constant double teams if we had a 2nd receiver capable of affecting another team's defensive game plan. Right now I don't think a combination Price, Reed and Parrish can get it done. I find Antonio Bryant intriguing: yes he is an A-Hole with a litany of transgressions but I think one of the more physically gifted receivers in the NFL, I love the way he attacks the ball not afraid to go over the middle. IMO its a high risk, high reward move.

     

    Kelley Washington (6'3) the bengals 4th reciever is another guy to keep on eye on as an "under the radar guy" he has been behind gifted recievers in Cincy eg. Chad Johnson, T.J Houshmanzadeh, Chris Henry. But has shown flashes of skill in limited playing time. It would be especially nice to get a big guy for the red zone someone who can get up and get the ball at its highest point.

  13. Its hard not to be impressed with his physical measurables, but a common theme im hearing is soft. who cares if your 6'8 pushing 350 if you don't have a nasty streak in you, you're useless. I mean part of football is the willingness to line up in front of your man and physically dominate him for 60 minutes. I get the impression the Walker is more than happy to collect a pay cheque block an occaisional FG and just live a life of general comfortability (but maybe im reading too much into it). Perhaps a switch back to Gaurd will get him motivated because he will have less responsibilities, regardless someone needs to light a fire under this guy because he is defintely a physical speciman.

     

    EDIT: I would have prefered a guy like Max Starks Pitt's restricted F.A I think he is played out of position at RT in Pitt and struggles in the pass block but i think he would be a perfect candidate for a switch to guard cause when he gets his hands on you he just mauls you and drive blocks you to the ground.

  14. if we got marshaun and resigned a-train

    and hopefully pick up griffith off FA

     

    we would have a stacked backfield

     

    Im going to have to point out its spelt Marshawn. Don't mean to be a prick but you're oppinion loses come credibility when you misspell the player's name that your advising the bills to draft. 12 would be way too high for him IMO, but the good news is he had a terrible combine with many of the other RB's out performing him in shuttles and cone drills. Also I could see his attitude being a bit of question mark that might effect his draft status (he had charges of assault and battery filed against him that were later dropped because lack of evidence, the woman claimed he choked her and sexually assaulted her) secondly the clip of him drivig around in the golf cart after the win although hillarious sort of of points to a me a first attitude something that some GM's see as warning signs. Recently scouts have criticized his up right running style. All im saying is these perceived criticisms of Lynch might make him a candidate for a spectacular fall of his draft stock eg. Lendale White and somehow he could be available when the bills pick at 43 ( although i highly doubt it) or the bills could trade up to the late first rd if they wanted to get him.

     

    I like the fact he is just turning 21 (apri 22ndl) has been a durable back over his career at Cal without taking too much of beating and he is an excellent receiver out of the back field. Defintely a guy to keep an eye on.

  15. If you watched any niner games you would realize he basically sucks.

     

    That's an assine comment. I have watched a lot of Antonio Bryant including his career at Pitt where he won the Fred Biletnikoff Award as sophmore. I think he is one of the most talented and physically gifted of any of the WR's in the NFL.

     

    Whether or not Bryant and his baggage are good fit for the Bills is certainly debatable, his talent however is not. Don't dumb down the debate with comments like "he sucks" - - from a skill standpoint Antonio Bryant would be significant upgrade over [not so]Peerless Price and Josh Reed at.

     

    Lastly I would add this. Buffalo is not the most desireable place for Free Agents we have issues competing with other teams based on: (1) location, (2) ability to offer huge sums of money up front ( unlike the Redskins) (3) are recent struggles standings wise (4) we lack a really marketable player (LT, Vince Young, Chad Johnson) who can be used as freeagent magnet to convince other NFL players to hop on board the Bills bandwagon.

     

    So at some point we have to take a calculated risk on a high reward, high risk high reward player.

  16. SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- The San Francisco 49ers waived troubled receiver Antonio Bryant on Thursday night, just one season after signing him to a lucrative four-year free-agent contract.

     

    Bryant caught 40 passes for a team-leading 733 yards last season, but repeatedly ran afoul of coach Mike Nolan's strict disciplinary standards. Bryant was arrested in November after a wild escapade in his orange Lamborghini, and he later angered Nolan for being late to a team meeting.

    Bryant Cut

     

    Bryant is a headcase but i abosolutely love this guy's game. One of the most talented recievers out there, him and Lee Evans would give use one of the most outstanding 1-2 WR combos in the entire NFL. Also i think Dick Jauron's style of coaching might suit Bryant's hot headed personality, plus he would have no national media attention in Buffalo.

  17. Henry tested through the roof at the combine not only in the 40 but also in the bench press and teh agility tests. His production at arizona was marginal to say the least. But if im the bills i go pack and carefully inspect the video to try and find out whether his low avg. was because of Henry's own inability or it was the blocking and scheming that that hurt Henry's stats.

  18. I understand that Ricky Williams is fully intent on making a comeback to the NFL and is cooperating with the NFL's drug testing lab and plans to file an appeal soon for reinstatement soon.

     

    He had a mediocre CFL season last year plagued by injury. From the games I saw him in; Ricky Williams still turned the corner way too fast for a man his size which impressed me, especially live. Yet his statistics in the games he was healthy for were poor (4.8 avg anything under 5 in the cfl is generally considered a disappointment) this could be do to that fact the ARGOS had a notoriously poor running game, characterized by a bad o-line and poor schemes but it could be signal of his decline as a running back. His competitor and replacement was John Avery a former 1st rd NFL pick, XFL star and CFL veteran who averaged 0.5 more yards per carry than Ricky this year. Lastly I would add the CFL running game is a lot different from the NFLs and perhaps Ricky was ill-suited for that style of play.

     

    I guess my question would be, what his deal? can he only comeback and play? or is it only for the Dolphins? if it was possible would it worth the risk for the Bills to sign him (they could use depth at RB and there is the simplistic Toronto Buffalo connection)? does he have anything left in tank? does he even want to play football or does he simply see it as a was to "get payed" since he forfeited so much money when he walked out on the team?

  19. I think Justin Griffith is the best full back in the entire league. its tough position to evaluate because you have to know the exact blocking scheme prior to the play but i never see this guy miss a block. It seems to me that Fairchild likes running out of double te and single back sets a lot though. I wonder if Griffith would fit our offense scheme?

     

    Fairchild is a graduate of the Mike Martz school of offense and i can never remember Matz being to big on blocking FB's but correct me if im wrong.

  20. Just like to add that Aaron Smith of Pittsburgh re-sign for what is believed to be around $25 million for 5 years. Smith and Kelsay tied in tackles and Kelsay had one more sack last year. Kelsay is also 3 years younger.

     

    But of course, the Steelers are geniuses and the Bills are run by senile old men. :thumbsup:

     

    First of all the Aaron Smith Chris Kelsay comparison is out of whack because their responsibilities are completely different. Smith is a 3-4 defensive end whose primary responsibility is gap control (3-4 ends have to controle both the B and C gaps) while keeping the o-lineman off the linebackers. Hence 3-4 defensive end's statistics, specifically Sacks are much lower on avg due to their role in a 3-4 defense. Julius Pepper's himself said he hates playing 3-4 cause its like playing DT Hence a purely statistical comparison between the two does little to demonstrate eithers effectiveness. I think most posters on this board would agree that Aaron Smith is an elite level 3-4 defensive end, conversly Kelsay a middle of the pack starting DE.

     

    As for my thoughts on the signing of Kelsay: Ultimately I will reserve my final judgement until i see the details of the contract, but if what is reported is true I have to say Bill's management/coaches must have seen something in Kelsay that I am missing. While I agree Kelsay is a serviceable DE, I thought a combination of Ryan Denney, Anthony Hargove and lower level FA or middle rd draft pick could have filled the Kelsay void at a much cheaper cost -- Saving the Bills lots of money to pursue either they're own free agents (Clements and London Fletcher) or to pursue other FAs/(potentially available players) in areas of need such as Steinbach, Max Starks, Adalius Thomas, Jared Allen, Micheal Turner, Cato June. To re-iterate I think the Bills overpayed for an avg DE in turn hampering their ability to sign other FA's. But here's hoping Chris Kelsay and the Bill's braintrust prove me wrong.

×
×
  • Create New...