If you and Peace were on the same page in your thoughts about the idea of being a poor Christian versus being a good person, I disagree with the premise of the argument. Specifically that the reward/salvation/heaven/eternal life, or however you wish to refer to it is based on any type of earned/deserved merit from a person whether they're Christian or not. So a simple answer doesn't suffice in my opinion. Again, I'll leave that alone unless you want a more in-depth response.
Political topics on a message board are bad enough, but religious topics usually turn out even worse (IMO). So I'm much more willing to discuss politics in a forum venue than I am religious beliefs. I may come across as harsh and rude to you when you talk about religion. But it has little to do with the fact that you aren't religious and don't believe in a god, but more to do with the disdain that you show for anyone that does.