The red zone is more than just the first 5 yards. I'm just going off what I saw from last season and whenever we got within the 5 yard line I noticed Marshawn was put in when he was healthy. And those stats do at least partially back up what I was saying. Jackson had, like you said, almost exactly double the carries compared to only having 30 red zone touches to the 20 that Marshawn had showing that Marshawn had the ball in the red zone a lot compared to having half the touches Freddy had. Regardless, I'm just trying to argue that Freddy is a very talented back and that the TD stat doesn't determine the better back.