"all he does is win" is a copout for when someone can't quantify how a person is a good football player. See- Trent Edwards the past few years (not this year). "He's got poise, he just wins games, etc"
yeah, except the Colts (who are #1 in scoring defense so far this year, btw) have the superstars in place to where they can just plug in JAGs at critical positions and still succeed.
*inane
How do you know that it wasn't Manning that made these offensive players? Edgerrin James was garbage after Indy let him walk via FA. Brandon Stokely? He is a never-was. Out of his ten year career, he put up a third (basically) of his stats that one big year in Indy.
and you can flip it around by saying "I can only imagine the winning Manning would do if he were surrounded by a top-5 defense all of these years"