I'm new to the board, but have been a Bills fan for 30 years...
I've seen QBs great (Kelly), good (Ferguson), average (Flutie), below average (Reich) and hopeless (Johnson).
Right now, I'd slot Losman in between "below average" and "hopeless".
Holcomb isn't much better either, making this the worst QB controversy since Holcomb vs. Couch in Cleveland a couple of years ago.
I would LOVE to be proven wrong about JP, but he could go down as final proof that the Pittsburgh Steelers of the late 1990's were all about Cowher and not about Donahoe.