I'm just tired of people making excuses for a guy who just can't cut it at this level. Its such a common tale its maddening that people still defend a guy who two teams gave up on after a year and a half after he was a top ten pick. I'd encourage people to go watch his AZ tape. I watched a bunch last year before the draft to see why they were gonna give up on him after a year and by game 6 I would have benched him myself. Yes thats a bad team and not well coached but Rosen was awful. No anticipation, no zip, late on reads, just bad. He looked closer to Peterman than a viable starter. The fact their was any debate over whether to keep him or draft Murray is laughable.
If there was any sign of progress or a glimmer of hope, no way he gets pulled for Fitz after Fitz was benched. I'd argue that if the Dolphins were in fact tanking, they would have kept playing Rosen. Playing Fitz was their only hope of winning a game and they knew it.