I ended up going to Grand Central, and it was a blast. It filled up pretty good, probably around 30 people all decked out in Bills gear. Lots of hootin', hollerin', and high fivin' all around, and the Shout song after every score. Very fun. The wings only get a 6 out of 10, though.
I'd probably try The Laughing Man next time just to compare, but I'd go back there.