Albany,n.y.

The decisions have been based on being in win-now mode. They didn't want to take the time to reset & develop a QB of their own, so ever since the year after Luck retired they have been bringing in guys who were good once and hoping to get a good season out of them. Only Wentz had any chance of being there a while & they (correctly) dumped him after 1 season.

The Colts have had 5 different starting QBs in 5 straight seasons if you only can give them a credit for 1 each year. Assuming Ehlinger doesn't start next year, 6 starting QBs in 6 straight seasons with a different guy each year could end up being a record that will never be broken.

I don't get the skepticism. The Tweet is dated before the draft as are some of the replies. It was confirmed after the draft by Beane that the trade to 5 with Denver was real, with those exact picks being a part of the trade. However, that Tweet was 20 days before the draft so the order may have changed a little after final visits. As it appears on the board, Mayfield's visit was scheduled for 4/9. https://buffalonews.com/sports/bills/report-bills-meeting-with-quarterback-baker-mayfield-next-week/article_a1f6fc77-97c0-5d66-a385-a1528db47e25.html Mayfield will visit the Bills next Monday and Tuesday, April 9 and 10, according to Mike Jones of USA Today. If Rudolph was the only guy left at 7, the Bills wouldn't have traded up. Look at the board again, the only 3 QBs the Bills were willing to trade up for were in order, Allen, Darnold & Mayfield. Most likely with no trade & none of the top 4 left by 12, the Bills take Edmunds at 12 & keep picks 21, 53, 56 and 65. They could have taken Rudolph with one of the 2nd rounders or pick 65 at the top of the 3rd round since all of those picks were above where Pittsburgh picked Rudolph in the 3rd round. I doubt they would have used pick 21 on Rudolph based on the fact that he fell to the middle of the 3rd round and Beane has proven over the years that he wouldn't have overrated a player by 2 rounds.

When KC won the Super Bowl he played a great game. As the game progressed I kept saying to myself "Please don't give Sammy Watkins the MVP", fortunately it went to Mahomes & not Sammy.

This was from Sal's Twitter. The reason I posted it is because Sal has been talking about going to NYC and Yankee Stadium with his son while on WGR the last few days. I though it was a nice story that Sal and Max made it to the game. If Sal hadn't been telling the story on the radio the last few days I wouldn't have posted it, but I though some of the listeners would be glad to see they made it to the game. Obviously the detractors aren't fans of Sal, who is one of the few people on WGR worth listening to.

Since I grew up in the NY Metro area I went to my 1st Yankee game with my father at age 9. I appreciate the joy Sal & Max had going to the game.

It was needed. Your response wasn't. Go pee in some cornflakes when you go to Wegmans looking for Howard.

https://twitter.com/SalSports/status/1583927989318070272/photo/1

I still remember the time one of our fellow posters thought you were Billy Shaw and got mad at another poster for not showing you the proper respect that a Bills icon deserves.

I was sitting at my desk during lunchtime (I would never go on the internet during work hours 😉) and since our office was in downtown Albany I chose my name. I made a typo not capitalizing the N & Y and just left it there all these years.

He's a sports reporter for CNN.

A lot of times when a team unexpectedly trades or waives a player, people question why without realizing that the coaches see the guy all week at practice when the rest of the league and fans only see the guy on Sundays. I think it's easier for the team a declining player or a bust draft choice is on to properly evaluate him than any other team & all fans. Carroll saw him just about every day last year in a 7-10 season & very well could have concluded Russ' best days were behind him. All Denver had was gameday films and maybe a pro scout or 2 who saw him play live in a game or 2. Another possibility was Pete saw how swelled his head had become & no longer wanted to deal with the guy.

It should have been titled "Disabled Man" , not Old Man.

It's still a QB driven league. Even if SF gets to the Super Bowl, it's going to be Jimmy G vs a franchise QB from the AFC (hopefully Josh Allen). This reminds me of the time back in 2019 when I looked at an upcoming December night game Bills at Steelers where Pittsburgh was favored and thought Josh Allen vs Duck Hodges, laughed and then raced to the casino to bet the Bills on the money line.

I think he'd clear waivers & end up on a practice squad. Maybe we'll find out within the next year who is right because as of now it's too speculative to be anything other than an opinion.

The only way that's happening is if we get nothing back in return but give them a 3rd to take Moss off our hands. OK, time to ask a serious question: Why are there so many posters who believe Zack Moss, who has no trade value and might not even get picked up if we waived him, is someone any other NFL team would trade for? His career appears to be following in the footsteps of Robert Foster.

Kiper actually did retire after Clausen didn't become a star. Clausen lasted through the 2013 season with Carolina before moving on to Chicago. Kiper never printed another draft report book after the 2013 edition. In that final report his top 2 QBs were 1) Geno Smith and 2) Matt Barkley. He had EJ 6th. It may have taken 9 years, but Kiper did get the 2013 QB class as correct as could be. NO other QB but those 2 is still in the league. In retrospect, Kiper did a better job than Buddy Nix and his assistant at the time, Doug Whaley.

Mel Kiper said the same thing on the ESPN broadcast of the 2018 draft, comparing him with Randy Johnson. It starts around the 1:10 mark:

Actually, no competent NFL scouting department would give a damn about comparable statistical data on college QBs. The scouts look at film & in game situations, not sheets of paper. The management also talks to a prospect they are thinking of using a 1st round pick on as well as his former coaches. Here's a good example: Do you really think you can take college QB stats of a California or Florida QB and compare them with stats of any QB playing in bad weather states? How about one who played all the teams' home games in a dome? There's no such thing as historical data on college QBs. Film, interviews and watching live games is what scouting top college players is all about, not some prior data based on statistics. I remember Beane talking about some of the reasons for drafting Josh. Among them was a game in bad weather where Josh almost single handedly willed Wyoming to victory but on the stat sheet he looked horrible. That can't be taken into account in trying to use comparable historical data because there is none. Beane has talked about the (at least) 3 interviews with Josh, at the combine, Wyoming & Orchard Park, He even spoke of how Josh reacted with the office staff at One Bills Drive. Then there was the film study of every game. There's no way to quantify a complete scouting report on any individual and compare it to any historical data. You might get lucky if you can ever find 2 similar scouting reports on 2 different franchise QBs, because I don't think a competent final report can be compared to another player unless they had almost identical circumstances.

He was not terrible in his 1st year. Stat boys will say that but nobody who watched him play every game and took into consideration who was around him would say that if they are in the visual fan column. He was basically QBing a 2-14 team, yet his record as a starter was 5-6 and one of those loses was a game Peterman came in & lost for the Bills. He showed flashes of brilliance from his 2nd start on. He willed the Bills to victory in half the games he started & finished. I never considered him terrible and had all the confidence in the world he'd lead the Bills to a lot of wins in his 2nd season after watching him play as a rookie. In fact, I cashed a bunch of future bets on the Bills in 2019 because I knew I didn't see terrible in 2018.

Looks like his wife is from Buffalo or was living there in 1992. I don't know why he was in Buffalo-maybe playing against the Bisons. Hoffman met his wife Tracy in Buffalo, New York, in 1992, where she was a real estate agent and a member of the National Football League's Buffalo Bills cheerleading squad. He asked her to marry him in 1993 while she was on the field during Super Bowl XXVII (which the Bills lost to the Dallas Cowboys, 52–17).[8] Hoffman and his wife have three sons: Brody, Quinn, and Wyatt.[127] The family lived in a house in Rancho Santa Fe, California, for nearly two decades before selling it in 2019.[210]

Nope, So. Cal.

The source was Dan Snyder, from the latest addition to his blackmail file. 😀

In the NFL the employees make more than their bosses: I order of salaries: Players>Coaches>GMs.

Have you ever been to Highmark? Screaming, standing and blocking views is the standard.