Albany,n.y.

According to some posters that means Brown & Glab hate Coleman.

Those were the best examples of people asking why I hated someone I didn't hate. I observed the actions of the rest of the GMs who let Brohm go by & was flamed because people like you said "I saw him play in college". I can't come up with others because I haven't observed many cases where the actions of NFL professionals have indicated they don't think much of a player and it applied to someone on the Buffalo Bills. After Arizona dumped Rosen after 1 year I drew the same conclusion, but his main supporter was on a different board, so you probably didn't see the flaming then. The reaction that I hate a player because I see a problem that the player has with management that draws an overreaction that I don't like the guy is way over the top. The times I notice this aren't often, but every time I do, people go way over the top & say I don't like the guy. Nothing could be further than the truth. I can't think of any Bills player I've ever disliked when he was on the team. Coleman may make the team, but his future in Buffalo is on very thin ice. There are just too many WRs on the roster better than him: Shakir, Palmer, Moore & Samuel. That puts him as WR #5 IMO. If a rookie WR shines in preseason, Coleman will have trouble making the team. There are just too many receiving options including the RBs & TEs that it will be very difficult for Coleman to get targets & be much of a factor in this offense. If there's a player who opens eyes as a 5th receiver who looks better than Coleman in August, Beane will cut his losses & take a draft choice for Coleman. I'm sure there are other teams where Coleman wouldn't be the 5th best WR, but in Buffalo, he currently is, no matter what preseason depth chart you might find on the internet.

Looks like Dak isn't recovered from his injury.😄

I have nothing against Coleman. I'm just observing the roster. Were you one of the guys who asked me the same question when I warned against Nathan Peterman & Brian Brohm? Every time I make a roster observation the dreamers think I hate the guy, when I just see there's no path for him. I hope he proves me wrong, but he's already buried deep on the depth chart which usually indicates one foot out the door.

Trading for a low round pick, not cutting.

The fact that Beane signed 3 veteran WRs in the offseason may be indicative that he's seen enough of Coleman that he's not sold on the guy. There's rushing to conclusions and there's also observing the actions of a team's management-two totally different things where it may look like the same conclusion. The Bills are going to keep the top 5 or 6 WRs, and unfortunately for Coleman, he may not be one of them.

Considering Keon could easily be 5th on the depth chart, I think there's a good chance he doesn't make the team. Probably goes for a 5th or 6th by late August, early September. All it will take is a rookie or new WR who can return kicks showing more than him in preseason.

If Robbins is as bad as you say, chances are we'll be picking up a guy who gets cut in September by another team like we did with Martin a few years ago.

Brown doesn't even rise to the joke category. He was benched in the UFL after 3 games & never played in another game. .

The #1 job of the backup QB is to be Josh Allen's close friend. So the best way to see who will be the backup is look who went to Josh's wedding. I saw photos of Trubisky & Buechele, but no Mike White. So my guess is the only QB who can beat out Trubisky is Buechele. Your drift is total BS. Brown couldn't even complete 50% in the UFL this year. He played in only 3 games, sucked & got benched. Brown is much worse than any QB on the Bills roster.

Guaranteeing 95% vs 100% is getting into the ridiculous mode. So, you're paying a guy $10 million, and you're guaranteeing $9.5 million for 4 years. The difference is $125,000 a year-chicken feed to NFL teams. What's going to happen is the teams that care about getting their rookies in camp on time will figure out the nit-picking isn't worth it, while teams like the Bengals will let their rookies come in late over a few $ of guaranteed $. Or the players will realize 95% is close enough & get themselves signed. If the teams don't want to guarantee the contracts of 2nd rounders, trade out of the 2nd round, or have enough confidence in the players you are drafting.

They had horrible scouts & it didn't take the coaching staffs long to figure they had drafted a QB bust. You can't develop a guy who sucks, and it's usually the coaching staff that sees the guy more than anyone else, practicing all week, that realizes the guy has nothing long before the fans who see him once a week, at best, do. Even the worst coaches know a player who has nothing.

It may not be enough for fans, but often it is enough for the team's management who see the guy in practice every day. Arizona couldn't wait to dump Josh Rosen after his rookie year. I'm guessing the thing that got Kingsbury the HC job was he wanted to install an offense that wasn't suited to Josh Rosen (although it turned out no NFL offense was). Marrone was basically done with EJ after his rookie year & quit as soon as Orton did instead of coaching EJ another season.

It depends on why he doesn't. If it's because the guys in front of him on the depth chart are playing like Pro Bowlers, and outperforming both Worthy & Coleman will it really matter?

I remember Josh's rookie year a lot different than you do. I saw the flashes of brilliance you want to see in a rookie & thought he was the answer at QB. If you didn't think much of his rookie year, you were relying too much on stats. Visually, he had "it". I was so confident in his ability that the next year I was all over Bills futures & won big. I also had the audacity to tell a Jets fan on my bus on opening day 2019 that Josh was a future HOFer. I guess since I rely on my eyes and never on stats, I remember Josh's rookie year a lot differently.