
mushypeaches
Community Member-
Posts
962 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by mushypeaches
-
I'm more willing to bet that we're only keeping 6 WR's and utilizing TE's & RB's more often in traditional WR sets. So it will much more likely come down to which of the marginal guys have ST skills & roles than in previous years where we keep 7 WR's and have 1 in just a return role (like Andre Roberts, etc) Diggs Davis Crowder McKenzie Shakir Kumerow
-
Jim Kelly on the all time passing list
mushypeaches replied to Marlton Bills's topic in The Stadium Wall
I love Jim Kelly as much as the next guy, but he was not a great passer. He did happen to have command of an innovative offense, and was often a better passer than the guys on the opposite sideline. But re-watching old games, his mechanics and decision-making were frequently awful, and as he lost mobility and arm strength during the second half of his career, it was clear that we were often winning games in spite of Jim Kelly, and not because of anything he was doing as a QB. Yes, many will argue correctly that it was a different era, blah blah blah. But Jim Kelly would struggle to be a competent starting QB in today's NFL. The guys are that much more talented, accurate, etc. I will always give Jim Kelly high marks for his leadership and toughness, but it's night and day vs what Josh Allen brings in today's NFL -
Allen tied for 5th lowest checkdown rate in NFL
mushypeaches replied to Big Turk's topic in The Stadium Wall
"Winning games is hard in the NFL" -Dick Jauron -
Look at how many solid players we drafted in 2018 besides JA
mushypeaches replied to BillsFan619's topic in The Stadium Wall
We currently have SIX draft picks from the 2017-2018 classes that have so far received second contracts from the Bills (with Edmunds still TBD), which literally has not occurred since before free agency changed the rules of the game entirely. That's EXACTLY what we needed to achieve when we brought McDermott & Beane on five years ago. Draft - Develop - Retain Now we have a whole generation of young veteran leaders to continue driving the culture that we've set in place. The next set of drafts will hopefully keep the chains in motion At the very least, from 2019, we'll be keeping Ed Oliver & Dawson Knox, with Jaquon Johnson a decent chance just based on his special teams work -
I'm a big fan of this in terms of being able to retain and develop players who need more time in your system or just reps with the coaching staff in order to be "game ready". This especially helps teams like the Bills who have much more of an established 53-man roster and risk losing talent to other teams without having a viable alternative in the Practice Squad
-
so what we're hearing is that all 3 of our division rivals won the offseason wake me up in September...
-
Titans are a 6 win team next year - they're ready to implode
-
So Who Will Not Be a Bill by September?
mushypeaches replied to BillsfaninSB's topic in The Stadium Wall
Zack Moss better report to camp in one hell of a good shape -
That will help them to keep Kyler Murray... SMFH
-
I thought this would be an interesting exercise to look at with a full 4 months to go before the season starts. In many years, it's easy to pick out 6-8 coaches that seem to be on their last legs and need a miracle to make it past the upcoming season. With the unprecedented number of 1st & 2nd year coaches this year, it becomes a little bit more difficult, but I'll try to rank who I think will be out by Black Monday: Matt Rhule (Carolina) - this organization is just flailing about with the continuous mediocre QB carousel and an owner who hasn't won yet and doesn't seem to be the most patient guy around. Plus - he doesn't seem to have a lot of respect from players and doesn't seem to be much of a game-day coach either. It's hard to see this team winning more than 6 games, and he'll be done after Year 3. Rhule is far and away the odds-on favorite and a big game from anyone at #2 and lower on this list. Mike McCarthy (Dallas) - I gave a lot of thought to Kliff Kingsbury in this space, as I think he's "all hat, no cattle". But then I looked it up and saw that Arizona gave him a 6 year extension (!). So it has to be McCarthy, who with all the talent they have on the Cowboys, continues to be a raging tire fire of a game-day coach, as evidenced by the debacle at the end of their last playoff game. I get that Jerry Jones is often overly loyal to coaches that he can push around (Jason Garrett), but I can't see McCarthy lasting past this season with an older and less talented roster. Ron Rivera (Washington) - hard to believe that he comes in at #3 on my list with all the hard work that he's done to help improve the image and professionalism of that sorry franchise. But he's had consecutive 7 win seasons to start his tenure there, which again, might be seen as a positive given all the turmoil at QB, but he's stuck with Jeff George 2.0 in Carson Wentz, who you can't help but think is going to be a disaster in Washington. Plus, the overall team just isn't that talented either, so you have to wonder if Dan Snyder pulls the plug after this season Pete Carroll (Seattle) - amazing to see how far this franchise has fallen. Their drafting and personnel decisions have been a mess the past few years and I think that Carroll's act has grown stale as well. He's now on the wrong side of 70 and another mediocre season could see him walk away, if not fired outright. Lovie Smith (Houston) - does he even see year #2 after how ownership treated David Culley? They're not going to win more than 5 games with Davis Mills and a young roster and Smith just seems to be another placeholder for when they draft a top QB next year and pair him with some rising offensive mind. Mike Vrabel (Tennessee) - he's been a solid coach for that organization, but he doesn't seem to be on the same page with ownership and/or his GM, and after last year's playoff debacle, I think the Titans could plummet a long way this season, especially if they have more major injuries or Tannehill falls off a cliff. Kevin Stefanski (Cleveland) - going into a pivotal year #3 - the first season was a raging success, but they went through a lot of organizational upheaval in 2021, and this team could go south quickly in a tough AFC, especially if Watson is suspended for a significant length of time, or if they just lose a lot of tough games. Never count out Cleveland to have a quick trigger finger with coaching staffs. Bill Belichick (Satan's Armpit) - he's earned the right to go out on his own terms, but with a noodle armed QB and another underwhelming draft, could this be the year that he walks away? I hope so after a 6-11 type season! So that's my outlook on May 1. I'm sure that many will have different opinions about the rankings but I thought this was a good conversation starter.
-
Poll: How would you grade the Bills overall draft?
mushypeaches replied to Lost's topic in The Stadium Wall
I gave it a B+ because the team focused largely on positions of specific need. When you don't have a lot of big gaping talent holes, I think you can do this, and Beane did it in a measured manner. Elam - we needed an infusion of top end talent at the position, regardless of White's status for the beginning of the year Cook - again, adding talent to the room, especially on the pass catching side. Zach Moss was already two steps out the door, and we're not likely to give Singletary a big second contract either Bernard - LB was a sneaky need for this team and we needed an infusion of talent behind Edmunds & Milano. Ask yourself if you would want any of the ST depth guys behind those two playing significant snaps on defense this year... Shakir - different body type, but this feels like Gabe Davis 2.0. Great value for the draft position and can step in and contribute in many versatile ways Araiza - what more do we need to say except I never want to see Matt Haack in a Bills uniform ever again -
I want a WR and a RB How they get there doesn't really matter (as long as we aren't trading next year's #1)
-
I think that his logic is sound, based on the last 5 years of the regime, as to why they might not draft a CB at 25 But I still want them to anyways. Can never have too many quality players at that position. We'll rue the day if Tre doesn't come back to form and we need Josh to score 40+ points just to win games.
-
Who is Your Favorite NFL Football TV Announcer of All Time ?
mushypeaches replied to T master's topic in The Stadium Wall
Solomon Wilcots announcing games for our Buffalo Bee-ows -
New Bills stadium deal is bad for taxpayers, according to Yahoo!
mushypeaches replied to JPL7's topic in The Stadium Wall
I'm sorry, did he miss the part about how we get to keep the Bills in Buffalo? SMFH- 168 replies
-
- 23
-
-
-
-
-
-
Sorry, it hurt my head too much to try to do a comprehensive review of all our first round failures. These were just the low-hanging fruit, but I know that the tree isn't bare
-
Aaron Maybin Mike Williams Erik Flowers JP Losman Walt Patulski
-
Derek Carr is the AFC's version of Kirk Cousins Not going to win anything significant because of him, but too scared to get rid of him and start fresh If I were a Raiders fan, I'd be thrilled to have been in QB purgatory for the last 10+ seasons and just signing up for at least 4 more
-
Noooooo... it's just that for a large number of fans, Edmunds doesn't pass the eye test. Yes, he's the captain of the defense, signal caller, etc. But the man just DOES NOT MAKE PLAYS. I can't recall a single game changing play that he's made in the last 4 years. NONE But yes, let's give him a handsome new contract because he has all the physical attributes, young, still growing, blah blah blah MLB is not a premium position in this league and I don't want Beane and the Bills overpaying for replaceable talent
-
You don't trade up or into the 1st round unless you're looking for a QB. That's the only position that you should part with any significant draft capital for. Otherwise, let the draft come to you. We circled the drain too many times during the drought years by chasing picks at other positions than QB. Conversely, we didn't pull the trigger on trades during the drafts that we really needed to find a QB
- 57 replies
-
- 11
-
-
-
-
-
Edmunds is a luxury that they can no longer afford after this year. I know that the coaches rave about his coverage skills, and leadership, and blah blah blah. But we need to pay the guys who MAKE PLAYS. Edmunds might get better, but he sure is going to get more expensive Let's get what we can from him on the field this year, but let's not be rolling out the checkbook for him unless he suddenly becomes a Top 3 MLB with the stats to back up that status.
-
God help us if he ever actually sees the field
-
I think that the push to 36 or even 40 teams is not that far on the horizon. The current owners strongly desire new, rich blood, and the outrageous expansion fees. Plus - it's the only real way to manage any kind of international growth