Randi Rhodes is one of the worst radio personalities ever. She is incoherent at times, angry in general, and not terribly bright. I honestly think she was a significant contributor to the fall of Air America. Among the liberals I know, most turned the channel when she came on. She is the liberal version of Sean Hannity in drag.
Now Rachel Maddow was at least intelligent, articulate, and had well thought out opinions even if I did disagree with her quite a bit. Also very funny.