I'm not concerned with who was better in the past. I don't think many people would argue against the fact that Mahomes was a better QB years ago. In 2024, Josh Allen is a better decision maker than Mahomes. That is clear from the TD - INT ratios which overwhelmingly favor Allen. A difference of 1 or 2 INTs could be explained away by luck and a few bad bounces. Allen has a 12-0 TD/INT ratio. Mahomes has a 6-8 TD/INT ratio.