Gotta respectfully disagree with you on Hamdan. He has very little real game experience under his belt and has most likely been working more with the backups than starters. We would be handing our offense to the 3rd string QB. Just watch what happens to NE with their 2nd string QB. You never know what can happen to starting QB's (Simms, Culpepper, Thiesman, etc.), so I'd rather hang on to JP this year for insurance reasons. Granted it was the first game of the year, but this team showed a lot of potential. If Edwards goes down, I think there is a BIG drop off between JP and Hamdan; otherwise JP would already be gone or Hamdan would be #2. Call me cautious, but I think we have to keep JP this season.