I hate grading individual moves. It is stupid, because there's no way a team looks at a single move as critical. I would only grade an entire offseason.
Criteria:
1. What to the FA and trades look like to influence the roster as a whole?
2. What goals cap-wise is the team trying to achieve in the next few years?
3. Aside from $$, has the team executed what is a cohesive plan to get better and address gaps?
4. How do this year's offseason moves set the team up for the draft for the next few years?
5. Has the team gotten rid of players that may not fit, or may be in decline?
Individual grades are just stupid, and it drives me crazy when fans do it, too. You just can't look at things like that.
Looking at this, I think the Bills did pretty well. They addressed the QB position the best they could. There were ZERO options at QB this offseason, and the Bills did what they could. The addressed major skill positions on offense that were holding the Bills back. The only gap is OG, but there weren't many first-tier options to go after. I expect the Bills will add a few players after the draft.
No. In terms of an overall plan, it makes more sense. Grading individual moves and not an entire offseason is stupid.