Here are the draft positions and receiving stats (games, rec, yds, yds/rec, TD) for all the first and second round WR in the 2024 draft:
4 mhj 6 17 279 16.4 4
6 malik nabers 4 35 386 11.0 3
9 rome odunze 6 17 246 14.5 1
23 btj 6 25 424 17.0 3
28 xavier worthy 5 12 179 14.9 2
31 ricky pearsall 0 0 0 0 0 [season ending injury shot in the chest in preseason, may return week 7 !!]
32 xavier legette 6 16 174 10.9 2
33 keon coleman 6 12 201 16.8 2
34 ladd mcconkey 5 19 219 11.5 2
37 ja'Lynn polk 6 10 78 7.8 1
52 adonai mitchell 6 8 79 9.9 0
Still a fairly small sample set but based on production so far, nothing here screams out to me "we should have taken that other guy at that spot or sold our future to move up and snag that dude!"
Yeah, trading up to grab BTJ would likely have worked out pretty well (so far) and I wouldn't have been opposed to it in principle if the compensation was sensible, but I think Keon is producing just fine compared to his peers so far. It remains to be seen if he can continue to level up his skill-set to get open vs NFL corners.