I'm grading the player on their draft position in relationship to their play. I’m NOT grading on potential for next year!
DT Marcell Dareus B
He was very good, and lasted the year. For the Bills that is an accomplishment in itself. For me to give him a higher grade he would have had to have made a few more plays even through the double teams. A Pro Bowl berth is my A+ so B for the 3rd overall pick is really good!
CB Aaron Williams C+
I personally expected more from Williams. Injuries hampered him I know, but my college professor wouldn’t accept excuses so I’ll pay it forward. He showed flashes but so did McKelvin. He was rated as a low first rounded and maybe that’s why I expected more.
ILB Kelvin Sheppard C+
He is another player I expected more from. His play got better as the year went on. I just wish I’d have seen a play from him that said “yep that’s the guy we need”.
S Da’Norris Searcy B-
Remember that I’m not rating these guys as compared to the rest of the class, and I expect more from the first picks. With that said I didn’t expect to even see this guy on the field. He held his own and that counts for our 5th pick in the draft.
OT Chris Hairston B+
Come on who thought this guy was going to be anywhere near capable of playing let alone as well as he did. If he would have stayed healthy I’d have given him an A just for the pure unexpected shock of how well he played at times. Do I think he’s the long term starter? Nope! I was just pleasantly surprised by him.
RB Johnny White C-
Did some things on ST, but I would have thought with Jackson going down he would have gotten some carries. Kudos to the Bills for bring in Choice because he did OK, but it doesn’t say much for White.
LB Chris White Pass/Fail
8 Tackles and 1 forced fumble. Early IR (which to me is a negative) I’m being kind here.
CB Justin Rogers B-
His ST work and him playing the nickel at the end of the season was more than you can ask of a player 7th round pick.
OL Mike Jasper D
He didn’t get cut so he didn’t get an F. He was elevated at the end of the season so he didn’t get a D-
Flame away!