Do you want the $, revenge, or both? If it's the $, a small amount of plotting will be needed. If you let some time go by, you could get in tight with him and then treat his abode like a looter treats a electronic store during a riot.
If revenge is soley what you seek, it will take a wee bit more work but the results will be worth it. What type of person is he? Where does he work? I would go right for the jugular, and target his job if it really means something to him. If they drug test at his employer, a little weed/coke pizza sprinkle would work nice. Just make sure he's drunk cuz otherwise he might notice the otherwise weird sensation the pizza is giving him.
No drug test? Find out the dirt with this !@#$. Is he married or in a serious relationship? This target is easy but a lot more volatile. Everybody has dirt. Find out what his is and spread it where needed. You may not get your $ back but ruining someones life can be invaluable.