Since you choose masochism, my final word will be to use your tactic and say that if Araiza had been your son, you'd be making the exact same arguments I and many others (including the DA) have. At some point you'd think you'd admit what you initially believed, and what you still think, is wrong.
A drafted punter won't be any cheaper. But if there's a promising prospect in the 6th (like Araiza was), sure, why not and let him compete.