Oh man I still love Peyton ... he is possibly my favorite QB of all time. I was simply making a point using him in this thread, thats all. I still love the guy.
THIS YEAR ALONE: McGahee has 100+ more yards, a better average, more first downs, and 2 less fumbles.
IN THEIR CAREERS: McGahee has 700+ more yards, more TD's, more 1st downs, and less fumbles.
So to me the fact that McGahee did not convert on a couple short yardage plays, does not mean that he is not much better than Jones.