Tiki Barber (last 3 years): 4594 rush yards, 24 TD's
4.8 YPC
175 receptions for 1,569 rec yards for 5 TD's
-------------------
If were going to look at Priest Holmes, we have to look at the last 3 years he actually played. In those 3 years he had
4590 rush yards, 56 Touchdowns
4.8 YPC
206 receptions ( ) for 1976 rec yards for 5 TD's
6 fumbles
-------------------
Ladanian Tomlinson
4,442 rush yards, 48 Touchdowns
4.5 YPC
204 receptions, for 1,536 rec yards for 7 TD's
11 fumbles
-------------------
Shaun Alexander
5,011 yards, 57 Touchdowns
4.8 YPC
not a good receiving back
14 fumbles
Now lets just go over this because BartinND seems to agree with WhozBack ...
Barber (out of this list) is 2nd in rushing yards, 4th in rushing TD's, 3rd in receptions, tied for 3rd in receiving TD's, 1st with the most fumbles, and is tied with all but 1 on this list with a 4.8 YPC
What you both were doing is including the 6 games from this year. You cant do that. RB numbers CAN fluctuate HUGE throughout a season .. especially with one of them (Alexander) being hurt.
Also. Tiki Barber has more 20+ yard runs than most of them but I see this as somewhat of a good/bad thing. Good that he is getting those long rungs, but bad because they arent going for TD's (he is the lowest in TD's), and it makes his YPC look higher than it should be. He is a 1 yard, 3 yard, 2 yard, 20 yard back. He isnt a consistant 5 yard, 3 yard, 6 yard back like say Tomlinson, who only gets about 7-8 long runs a year.
Personally I would say Tomlinson is much more valuable than Barber. Tomlinson has SLIGHTLY lower rushing yards, WAY more TD's, nearly 40 more receptions, 2 more receiving TD's, and 4 less fumbles.
Thats my case.