DrDawkinstein

Possibly better when you consider that most of Polian's star acquisitions were 1. brought in via early draft picks from the Bills being 2-12 for a few years in a row and 2. he was working with 12 ROUND DRAFTS. 12! 12 shots plus some he got from trades and what not. He had 13 picks in 1986. He hit on the first 2 (Ronnie Harmon and Will Wolford), if you count Harmon as a hit, and then... not much else to show for it. When you go back and look at the number of hits he had versus the number of picks he used, it is far worse than Beane's batting average. Plus. Polian didnt have the salary cap to worry about. It was all far simpler for GMs back then. Where does this line of questioning even come from? There is plenty of access to the draft process to see that Head Coaches, Asst Coaches, Scouts, etc all have great input into the picks. This is not some autonomous authoritative regime. Nor is it that way on any team. Go watch the discussions and debates the Cowboys room had at time of their picks throughout the draft. It wasnt the GM or any one person dictating anything. And that's with Jerry Jones in the room!

lol, that wasnt me. there was an actual thread yesterday yeah, started as dankenstein. i thought i had a good archive memory of the stuff that goes down here.

We need Tackles, and he proved his worth playing through that ACL in the Miami game. Unless we bring in another vet, I think he sticks around.

I would love to have a prime Brandon Spikes on this team.

haha, that was right after the Bills played down there in 2019. We won a tough fought game. Lawson and Phillips were jawing HARD and all over Lewan. Both had a really good game, I think Phillips had 3 sacks, and then baited Lewan into a bad penalty at the end that killed their drive. Good times. Love those guys.

Absolutely NOT

I was feeling B+/B (voted B). Glad to see all the higher grades here and in the press. We'll see how it all works out, but I always take the early grades to look at how the team addressed needs, got highly rated prospects, and maximized value.

7:05 of the Beane post-draft presser, he gets asked about not picking a DT. Check it out, but he basically says he did want to add 1 but the draft didnt fall their way for getting one, but he has things in the works to add another soon.

Either in Boettger's spot, on the PS, or cut outright since he was a late 7th and unlikely to ever actually play. Not counting on him for anything but camp body.

That's exactly where I am with it. They had so much capital, they could spend it. And they got all their guys and plenty of them. I dont care a bit what they paid.

Texans Steelers Eagles Lions In that order. With the Texans being the run away winner. However, much like the Jets last year, given their position and quantity of picks, they SHOULD be the runaway winner. They at least did what they should have, which is more than you can say for some other teams that have been in their position. edit: yall are right, ***** the lions

DAMMIT!!!

Gimme 2 of Vorhees/Joseph/Ojomo/Brandon Hill in the 7th and I'm ecstatic

The fact that next year's class has Marvin Harrison Jr makes it 10x the entire 2023 class on him alone.

Or if they want to trade up from 32

Dang it! I was about to forget all about this draft but now you got my hopes up for something. Using a 7th on Vorhees would be a great move, imo

I like the idea of using one of those 7ths on Vorhees

Go to the live draft thread where it is being discussed.

For real. I get that its a cliche. But the difference is staggering.

2024 draft class is streets beyond this dump of a class. Stack picks to use to trade up next year.

These trade backs are stacking picks for next year. I dont blame him. There is no one left in this draft.

Brandon Beane hates this round Moved back to the 7th twice, but picked up 2 6ths for next year which is a much more talented draft.

Agreed. I'm hoping McBeane are past that whole "the roster is complete, rookies wont need to contribute right away" mindset. If we want to take a step from last year, we need what Kincaid and Torrence bring to the table to translate to our Offense this year.

At the end of the day (or camp to be precise), if nothing else works out, I'm fine with this.

That is a worst case scenario. Like a Tommy Doyle playing on a blown ACL, team getting cooked alive, worst case scenario.