Yes, but we're comparing the '81 weapons to the '05. '05 may have a bunch of potential, but it hasn't shown up this season. '81 Butler over '05 Moulds, '81 Lewis over '05 Lee, easy.
And yes, I'd take '81 Cribbs over '05 WM in a heartbeat right now. Will WM become better than Cribbs? I hope so and expect so, but right now he's as good a workhorse but not nearly the threat.