I'd give Jim a rating of 97 out of 100. I'd give Doug an 83.
To put it in perpsective.....Joe Montana, Tom Brady, John Elway , Dan Marino,Johnny Unitas, Dan Fouts all are at 100.
Steve Young 99.
Peyton Manning 98
Terry Bradshaw 98
Bret Favre 97
Jay Schroeder 47
JP Losman 60
Randall Cunningham 89
Jay Fiedler 61