Good post, John.
McD's motivtions, if those, are myopic in nature. Watkins, even if underperforming his draft status, still would have more value to the Bills than on the Rams. That he is not producing well with the LAR does not imply that he would have similar numbers on the Bills. The reasons are just too thin ot justify getting rid of him this year. ZayJones, as most draft picks, was not a sure thing. He may take time to develop or he may be a bust. But Watkins was a sure thing and should have been kept this year when other options were woeful and low. A coach and GM should not be getting rid of every player who is not an ideal fit in their system. That is why it is best to transition out into a different system. I would stretch this arugument and say that we should have attempted to keep Robert Woods also. Watkins-Woods-Jones would have been a very good combo. Jones would be brought along into the system and if he was a hit, the Bills could part ways with Watkins in the next off season. I am also of the opinion that Boldin came on board just to be a mentor to Watkins while catching the occasional pass. At his stage of his career, he had nothing left to prove but he could point to how he pulled up Watkins to glory and then could walk off into the sunset.
McD should have managed Watkins as a coach should and taken Boldin's assistance in trying to challenge him to his true potential.