This is pretty fair. I havent seen Lamar play so cant tell his skills compared to Allen's. Allen has looked very good after that disastrous first half vs the Jets.
Having seen Baker spottily in his first game this season and then last night, I am very skeptical about how well he will do in the future. Also, having seen Darnold's games, I jst get the feeling he lacks the "it" factor. He is bland, makes many throws but is highly uninspiring. I realize this is a highly non-quantitative take but I can easily see him slide further once he sees the field.
This is a good take on Mayfield's showing last night: http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000001055959/article/what-we-learned-from-browns-win-over-jets-on-mnf
"4. Beckham's breakout night aside, Cleveland's offense was unsteady and uninspiring for the second straight week. Mayfield was sailing passes against a subpar Jets secondary, no one east of Odell could make plays in the passing game and the Browns were a woeful 4-for-13 on third downs. Baker threw the 18th interception of his young career with the Browns driving and the game in hand by forcing a speedball in the middle of the field. The miscue reeked of an overconfident gunslinger failing to manage the game correctly. Cleveland's attack has a long way to go to reach its offseason potential. Lucky for them, there are still 14 more opportunities to improve."
Rudolph and Rosen - we dont have enough data to know one way or another.
As I have said before, I just love the fact that so many (potentially) good to great QBs have entered the league in the past 3 years. Very exciting to see the future of the NFL in their hands. Ofcourse, I will hope that Allen turns out to be the one with the most rings, but we all should be looking forward to several good QB battles in the years ahead.