I'm not sure if you saw the game yesterday, but for those that did not, let me say that McGahee is the REAL DEAL. He's electric, he's powerful, he's exciting and he was amped up. Baring injury, this guy will be an elite back in the NFL for a long time to come...believe it.
As far as the pick goes, I'd personally say that it was TD's pick to gamble with. He single-handedly manufactured the pick from nothing at all when he tagged Peerless Price and held out for the 1st rounder from Atlanta - Price was gone anyway. He produced it out of thin air and spent it as he saw fit. The thing that nobody can answer is who should TD have taken anyway? Kelsay? That's the guy everyone was saying we should take at the time, but we got him in the second round regardless.
Personally, I'm really glad McGahee is on this team. I like Henry and all, but he has shown absolutely nothing this year and Willis seems to be a spark to get this offense going. Instead of bitching about needing another running back due to Henry's shortcomings this year, we've got one of the best young prospects in the league ready to step in now. Anyone who doesn't like the pick as of right now is just hating TD IMHO.
Willis! Willis! Willis! (I love the endzone)