Great post.
Also, to the guy who said Willis had huge holes to run through, he did.
You still have to give him credit for gaining yards, even if the holes were there.
Willis on third and long is a failure, at this point.
He is not a good receiver, and I'm not going to get into the pass blocking.
I hope Willis pans out in Buffalo, but won't be hurt if he's gone. He is not a star in this league, and not close to being a great player. (yet)
It is also ironic, some of Willis's biggest nuthuggers , are the same people that pick JP apart.
Even though running back is a much easier position to master, and there are cases where guys are great before their mental ability catches up with their physical ability. (same can't be said for QB)
I personally think this is the first season Willis is completely healthy, and will go a long way in determining what kind of player he's gonna be. He has shown flashes of brilliance, and moments of idiotic behavior on the field, much like a young QB we have.
It wouldn't be fair of me, or anybody, to defend JP and throw Willis under the bus. I think they both will be just fine, but Willis has the ability to be a superstar.