Butler made the playoffs as GM in 1993 (This was Polians team with no real work from Butler), 1995, (still a lot of guys that Polian brought here), 1996 (a few more Butler guys spread in there), 1998 (This was a Butler team), and 1999 (Also a Butler team).
He was GM for 8 years and we made it 4 times. Not good, but better then TD has done.
I still think he was a terrible GM though.