sullim4

I am not a big Yeezus fan but I think he has a valid point - our coaching staff isn't exactly equipped to smooth the edges on a physically gifted quarterback that has issues with his mechanics. This is why I think McCarron starts this year, with Allen watching him on the bench. At least I hope that's the case. The OL has regressed and I could easily see a situation where Allen gets thrown to the wolves a la Peterman and the fanbase jumps down his throat because his first game is terrible. There's no recovering from that, just ask Nate.

It's the Pegula Jet!!!

Uncatchable. His arm is strong enough to throw it over everyone's head, even at awkward angles while on the run. Looking at his stats, he averages slightly less than 2 sacks per game. That's pretty good. I still don't like the pick but a lot of the comments here make him out to be JP Losman and I'm just not seeing that.

The one thing I will say in watching his tape last night is that he has a tendency to throw the ball away a lot rather than take sacks.

Agreed. Same thing was said about Whaley and EJ, and look what happened to those two...

Going to go with Yolo's meme again...

He should just take Darnold then. This is such an easy selection for the Giants IMO and screws over the Bills. If I were a Giants fan, I would be going insane if they pass over both Darnold and Rosen at #2 or trade the pick away. 1. Mayfield 2. Darnold 3. Rosen 4. Barkley 5. Allen to BUF via trade with DEN Also possible, if Cleveland really does like Josh Allen, is to trade Mayfield to Buffalo for Allen + some large haul of picks.

That's my feeling as well if CLE passes on him. If I were a Giants fan, I'd be super pissed if my team passed on a quarterback...

The tin foil hat side of me wonders if Belichick's sith lords dug all of this up and are feeding this to the press in the hopes that they can jump up in the first to grab him...

Gilbret?!? Gibran "Chroise" Hamdan isn't happy!

Riley Ferguson would never say these things...

Gotta love his pinned tweet... O RLY?

This sounds plausible but it'd have to be someone who resides in the Buffalo area year round, right? Who would that be? And who's going to hop on a flight at short notice to benefit the team that's trading him away?

I knew something was missing from TBD these days... the obligatory Pegula Jet thread goes well with all the rampant speculation!

Agree that bad news will be worse for server health. I think Allen is the worst case scenario. That's closely followed by not trading up and watching a team like Miami trade up with the Bucs or Colts to get the fourth quarterback, even if it is Allen, and having the Bills pick Jackson, Rudolph, or Mead's favorite QB Riley Ferguson.

On his 2017 list, Peterman was #4 and Chad Kelly was #5. Enough said.

If Whaley is the GM, there is no way we have both 12 and 22. So I highly doubt we'd have the third overall pick in this scenario.

Agree. I think if the Browns take Darnold, #2 becomes more of a possibility. If Cleveland takes Allen or Mayfield, then I think the Giants will take Darnold at #2, with the Jets taking whoever is left at #3. I think they need to either trade with Denver or New York. Selecting any later makes it very risky that the fourth quarterback will be off the board. Select pick #2/NYG if you think they will do a 3-way trade.

We're almost 72 hours away... seems like the right time to do this. I'll do an accounting come Friday morning - for now, give your best guess and your rationale behind it.

I'm with you. I don't want another mobile quarterback after TT. My order of preference on the top quarterbacks is Mayfield, Darnold, Allen, Rudolph, Rosen, and then Jackson. Rosen's talent is solid but he just screams bust to me due to his inability to work with teammates.

Wow, a frontloaded away slate. 5 road games vs 2 home games to start.

Drinking a Black Raven pale ale right now while on call... so in a way, we're already doing so.

I think it goes one of two ways, assuming NYG don't take a QB at 2: CLE: Allen NYG: Chubb NYJ: Darnold CLE: Barkley BUF: Mayfield OR CLE: Darnold NYG: Chubb NYJ: Mayfield CLE: Barkley BUF: Allen

Agree with this. He is not a process guy. I hope they end up with Mayfield but I have a feeling it's going to be Allen if they can get to 5.