Matt in KC

A few points are highlighted below that relate to the current discussion http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2015/05/11/nfl-statement-on-deflategate-discipline/

I remember them saying both, and specifically Vincent saying past behavior was considered. I thought maybe I had missed something. It is smart of them to not detail the punishment as there is a kind of gestalt here that comes with weighing a lot of things, some less certain than others.

Kelly, quick question: I have seen you repeatedly say the punishment was 2 games for cheating, 2 for obstruction. I have only seen that the punishment was for both, but not how much for each part. Are you sure somone specifically said two each, and if so, do you remember who?

Hey, that's not nice. I like to think of myself as a complexton! Do you think this skill more than offsets the mobility and age advantages of EJ and TT? Do you think all 3 QBS are continuing to improve?

Bummer. I have a lot of fond memories watching games he was calling. I didn't realize he was so old. I guess time keeps on slipping (x3) into the future. . . .

Nice post, KOK. I am hopeful EJ will take the starting job. At very least, he's not far behind the other 2 QBs. And I agree, he has the highest upside. Most of the EJ negativity is just media echo-chamber, I think, particularly clearly at the national level.

Un-pin?

QB1 hardly plays in the first preseason game, right? I'm glad EJ and TT will get a lot more playing time.

Excellent!

I'm expecting something like this from Goodwin this year: 20 catches for 375 yards and 3 TDs

I can't imagine a kid having a healthier hobby. I have a hard time understanding how any Bills fan wouldn't enthusiasticly support Goodwin following his dream, and be proud of him. In my opinion, that negativity is just bizarro Buffalo defeatist bullcrap, preemptively bracing for some future disappointment. Go Bills! Go USA!

I hope that's it. It's going to be Fred's body, not his heart that determines if he has another season in him, IMO.

I have thought one of the main reasons we have carried two kickers may be that Carpenters leg wears down after a full season of kicks. He was great when he could focus on just FGs. I wonder if he is being held out for that reason, if we might carry only him this year. Has anyone heard any specifics about the injury? It is only intuition at this point, but I think Rex let's vets sit in preseason if they aren't on the bubble. Does he have that reputation?

Joe Buscaglia @JoeBuscaglia Aaron Williams and Jerome Felton were fine according to Rex

He certainly seems strong enough and fast enough. I'm worried he has a tendency to lunge, and hasn't learned the technique subtleties he'll need to compete against the D-Line talent in the AFCE.

You never know

Easley's name being called a lot. Talk about rising to the challenge! I've thought he was likely safe for ST reasons, since I believe he is the top gunner in the league, but he's making himself hard to cut as a backup WR.

Does anyone at all refute that the officials set the balls to 12.5 psi according to one of the gauges before the game? The balls would have to get 80+ degrees colder to explain a 10% difference in pressure (assuming the same amount of air was in the balls and air pressure did not change significantly).

I think those two are really going to help each other get better.

This was the question: chris jackson‏@xhighway1 @SalSports At their peak from what you've seen which QB is the best? consistency aside if you always got all 3's best who would you pick?

What's up with all the name-calling? The Panthers one is directly addressed in the appeal decision on page 15: Read more here: http://www.charlotteobserver.com/sports/nfl/carolina-panthers/nfl-blog/article29140732.html#storylink=cpy

Someone lock this monster!

Is PUP to start the season the same as IR with designation to return? It sounds like players on PUP must sit out the first 6 games: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physically_unable_to_perform This is a better write-up that makes PUP and IR-designated to return separate. http://www.ninersnation.com/2015/7/23/9023391/nfl-pup-list-injured-reserve-nfi-list-rules-2015-san-francisco-49ers

So if Leodis isn't healthy by the start of the season what will his designation be, and impact on the cut-down to 53? IR with option to return? PUP?

Brain exploding... That's the problem with Cassel, he's just not consistent!