It's fine to have opinions, but I think basing your opinions on camp reports is like depending on a secondary source for your news or your historical information. It's always filtered and hence up for debate. Seeing things with your own eyes and identifying them holds much more weight. I think you show some nuance in your perspective, even if it tends negative. Others don't, and are just going to come here with all the reasons they think EJ sucks. They will disappear or change their tune if he plays well, and they will reappear when he struggles.
I base my opinions on those of people who break down the film or the All-22 shots, and those have generally been mixed for EJ. He's shown ups and downs, which is consistent with the idea that he was not meant to be thrown into the fire last year, and that he was going to take some time to develop.
I agree with you that there should be a better plan B, and that Kolb was a shaky one at best.