Great size... doesnt equal BIG.....especially for a RB...
As any scout what great size for a RB is......they will all answer the same....
LJ and Jackson are that exception in the bigger range.....were they have to be something special to make it...to have that package of size and 4.45 speed...its rare for a RB....usually your that big and that fast your a LB not a RB....
as for LT, Holmes are 5'10, Gore is 5'9 ....all weighing in the 215-225 area....so they dont exactly fit the smaller back type....
a guy like Bush makes it weighing 205 cause he has exceptional ability....he brings alot more to the table...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
and to Simon
Lynch, you say he isnt explosive...I disagree....I'd make my arguement but you'd throw them away, saying PAC-10 D's are weak...ok thats fine.....we disagree....
He doesnt have speed yet he runs a 4.45 -40.....Def above average...wouldnt you say....
One thing that you cant argue is that he is a complete back, the most complete back in this draft....do you agree to that....
you say he's not explosive enough to be a #12 pick...ok we disagree....
See the dude in my avatar...Lynch is him...with more speed, more agility, more athletism, better hands, better blocker, smarter, better overall football instincts...I'll take that at #12...
As for who is right or wrong ... we will have to wait and see....
save this we will bring it back in 2009