The originals will always be better because if you look at any other scifi file made during that time you will see most of them are a real hack job. The Original star wars was put together so well that you could actually believe that this all happened "A long time ago, in a galaxy far far away."
If the new three were shown to someone who has never seen star wars in their life first. I would bet that upon viewing the original 3 that person would think it is crap.
I have always liked the new 3. My reason being that i don't care if it was done with models or CGI. I don't go to see a movie for the graphics. I go to see it for the story. I knew that episodes 1-3 would put to rest the mystery of Darth Vadar. Episodes 4-6 only tell you that Darth Vadar is Luke's father and that he turned to the dark side. Episodes 1-6 is all about "The rise and fall" of Anakin Skywalker and how he would bring balance to the force.
Episode 3 was awesome. Mr. Lucas made it tie in so well with the original 3 because of details. Details like Obi picking up Anakin's lightsaber at the end and keeping it (we knew who it goes to). The little things like that made me like the movie so much better.
Alot of people don't like the cheesy love story shown in episodes 2-3 but it is pivotal because it caused Anakin to go to the dark side.
i was pleased with the movie and i want to see it again in the movies in a week or so.