The problem is that JP was nowhere NEAR the zip code of "terrible." Was he great? No. But he did more good than bad, and there are a lot more appropriate descriptions of his performance than "terrible." To me, "terrible" means he couldn't have done any worse than he did (and in that vein, I wonder what he'd say of Aaron Rodgers' performance ). But again (broken record), a 60% completion percentage, avoiding sacks, throwing the short pass well, converting 3rd downs, and make correct decisions most of the time, is pretty good. Was he perfect? No, but no QB is. I don't know, now that you mention Fez having the Broncos-Bills pre-season game from last year in his sig, maybe he was expecting JP to BE perfect with his passing?