I also don't get the comparisons of Maye to Josh at this stage - bc he is tall? Josh was a wild massive bull/stallion with a bazooka arm and 'accuracy issues' who looked to bowl people over (when he wasn't hurdling them). Maye throws a good deep ball and is mostly accurate and scrambles straight ahead. He doesn't match Josh for size, strength (arm and overall), athleticism, attitude or overall 'superman' traits. And some of those he will never have. I really don't look at him and think that Josh is what he will become. I don't see any 'superman' or 'alien' in him.
I think Stroud more than anyone when I think of Maye - people losing their minds Stroud's first year then everything coming back to earth once teams figure him out