Nice post Rome!
BTW. Don't let these dudes change your opinion on McNabb. He will be a HOFer. NO doubt. It only takes a person with half a brain to look at his accomplishments and realize he is indeed HOF worthy.
Where shall I start? Four straight NFC Championship appearances, five Pro Bowl appearances, 30K yards passing, 7 playoff appearances in 12 years with five of those making it to the NFC Championship game, close to 200 passing td's, offensive MVP runner-up, 3K yards rushing, etc etc. To top it all off, McNabb isn't even finished yet.
McNabb accomplished all of this without even having a great receiver to work with, other than T.O., as you astutely pointed out. Has anyone in the history of the game accomplished as much with so little surrounding talent that #5 worked with? It's hard to say, but I think not. He will be wearing a yellow jacket when he retires.
Here's a great article on the subject of McNabb and possibly making the "Hall".
http://www.zimbio.com/Donovan/articles/7/D...Nabb+Hall+Famer
Many of these people on this board couldn't spot a hall of fame QB if he smacked 'em in the mouth.