I think many of us understand the role Star is SUPPOSED to play.
He rarely plays it.
You can’t evaluate a player in a vacuum. Because of scare resources and a salary cap, personnel decisions have opportunity costs. Signing Star and paying him what they’ve paid him cost them other opportunities. That’s a fact. Viewing the investment they’ve made in him compared to what he’s actually given them, there is no way that they’re satisfied. Some of it was beyond their control, but that’s what happens when you overpay.
Separately I have my suspicions about whether the guy actually loves football, but that’s another matter.