A lot of people here like to use the "company line" bs when talking about most of the reporters, but I never really noticed that as much as others appear to.
I like Vic Carucci, he's solid, does a decent job.
Sal is ok. He's like talking to a passionate Bills fan. He has some good opinions and some really bad ones, but he's not afraid to say what he thinks. But he's never going to blow you away with his insights.
Jay Skurski is pretty solid. He's on Rich Gaenzler's show on the FAN quite a bit and I enjoy his takes. Rich is pretty tough to listen to though, he just babbles and bounces around all over the place, but the only one on at that time.
Tyler Dunne is pretty good thus far, he's not as bitter as the rest at the BN, but give it some time.
John Murphy is very good IMO, he has the most insight and runs a really good show.