Very good assessment JA!
Syesha had her best performance in weeks. Sometimes I think she believes her voice is better than it is and she bombs on the Whitney or Mariah songs. She did a very nice job this week.
Carly is just the opposite, she knows her limitations. Which is why she did not belt out the JC Superstar chorus, that disappointed me a little, but was probably a good move by her. Overall a very good performance.
Jason just doesn't have the sit down ballad presence nor the voice. He struggles without the guitar in his hands.
Brooke is the same as Jason, needs the guitar or piano to shine. Terrible performance, she always seems like she is on the verge of a nervous breakdown. I think her lack of confidence really shows and it's too bad because she could be great.
I thought David C's performance was very good. He struggled a bit on the softer versus, but he worked it out dog. He's going to be tough to beat!
David A had a good week, but he was a bit boring. I tend to day dream when he sings ballads for some reason, I don't know what it is, he just bores me at times. Although he does have a very good voice.
The bottom 2 have to be Jason and Brooke, with Jason getting the boot. Although I wouldn't be surprised if Brooke goes, Jason may have a bigger fan base with the young girls...