Yes, she should have been gone after rockin robin! Even though she is easy on the eyes, I couldn't wait for her songs to end. She is so awkward! Although I do believe if she had picked the right song, she could really sound good. But her song selection has been really out there.
Also, is it me, or does Lil yell just about every song? She does have some pipes, but damn! I think with some coaching, she could be really good though.