It amazes me that so many here who have never (or will never) face the pain of making this heartbreaking decision, can be so sure their opinion is the right one.
1. The pain of adoption: Having been raised in the time of the "back alley abortionists of the 50s and 60s, I faced this dilemna when my first love (and first lover) was killed in Viet Nam only 4 weeks after arriving. Later, learning of my pregnancy (yes, we used condoms), and being afraid to seek a dangerous (and illegal) termination of my pregnancy, I endured months of loathing from my parents, 2 months in an "unwed mothers home" in another state (where we were treated like lepers) and that awful "secret" delivery in a strange place. I held and nursed my daughter for the next few days while my mother managed to convince me of my selfishness, stupidity and irresponsibility in thinking I could take care of this child. So I signed the papers, kissed her goodbye and promised myself that her sweet face would be forever etched on my brain. After months of emptiness, the pain gradually found a corner of my heart where it would emerge every year on her birthday. It's a long story, but we searched for (and found) each other after 21 years and it has been a positive, beautiful experience, developing a relationship with her, meeting her adoptive parents and becoming an "extended" family.
2. The pain of Abortion: About two years after my divorce, I was in a loving relationship with a nice guy. I was a single mom with 3 kids at home, he was a single dad with dual custody of 4 children and whopping child support payments.
I was taking birth controls pills. I became pregnant. I was devastated. Money was tight - I had to work to take care of my children. I agonized over the decision to have an abortion because I felt it was wrong (and still do). But somehow I knew it was the right decision for my family at the time. Do I regret it? Yes, absolutely. The pain of ending my pregnancy will probably always be with me. Would I do it again? In the same circumstances, yes I would.
I've written this to point out that not all women are "irresponsible" with birth control. So many women are faced with these gut wrenching decisions in their life. There is no right answer. This issue will never be put to rest because there is no "right" decision - but I'm glad that my daughters live in a time when they at least have a legal choice about something that will affect them for a lifetime.