Offer 10M. If he doesn't want it trade him or he can sit for a year. The reason this fan base doesn't like divas is because we are blue collar bring you're lunch pal to work people.
I would like Garrett but that isn't going to help us next year against the Chiefs when we need yet another TD at the end of the game. We either need an offensive threat or a coach that knows what he's doing.
I don't think this is optimal. You're current DC has lost a vote of confidence. Now you bring in someone with more experience. Who's in charge? Is the new guy going to step all over the current one. This doesn't seem like a great working dynamic.