You can't prove that. You haven't watched all "top coaches" (and what comprises a top coach anyway?) games within the same period of time as McD. There just isn't a way to quantify this.
Just stop.
The flack this coach gets is mindboggling.
Oh i was screaming to decline it, thinking they'll try a long kick. What I wasn't thinking is that the Rams could NOT kick, and get the first down.
We're asking the coach to be 100% perfect all the time. And, making those pressured decisions within seconds, while we can all sit back afterwards, bat the different scenarios around, then call him out, after having the time to think things through.
I just think a lot of fans are being WAY unreasonable with McD. It's like ANY decision the guy makes HAS to be proven correct with gameplay, otherwise we should get a new coach. Its ridiculous imo.