I do have some leather shoes. It's just too hard to find any selection of non-leather shoes. I have a leather football too. Also, I eat eggs and cheese and yogurt. I feed meat-based foods to my dog and cat.
When I stopped eating meat, about 12 years ago, my goal was to gradually increase my vigilance against animal abuse. It hasn't really played out that way. I guess it turns out that I care, but I don't care enough to make the really tough sacrifices. The morality of these things is something that I struggle with. Another factor is that it's not really in my personality to be a crusader or the kind of guy who is actively at odds with other people. The tendency to just be a regular person who does the regular things is very strong. Also, I happen to have a strong aversion to joining any club or movement. The mob mentality of the extremist vegan types is as frightening to me as the blind lunacy of religious nuts. The only "granfalloon" I belong to is this weird brotherhood of Bills Fans.
The sad fact is that I just don't have the time or energy to always be the responsible consumer. The amount of research and vigilance required gets ridiculous and I kind of need to worry about other things and just live my life. I'm content with trying to be a good person, especially concerning the things that I can control day to day with the people (and animals) that I come into direct contact with. I can't deny there's some hypocrisy there, but I can live with it.