I agree he's in the top 5 or so. Hard to argue that he's better than P. Manning or Brees or Rivers. Rogers missed on a couple throws yesterday that would have been sure TD's. Ended up costing them the game. He played great overall, but he did miss a couple easy ones.
What's amazing to me is how many great QB performances we saw this year. Ten guys with over 4,000 yards. Five finished the season with over 100 QB rating (and four more in the high 90's). TD passes all over the place, etc...
Just one more thing that makes me painfully jealous as a Bills fan. How come everybody else gets to have all the fun?