Someone finally said it. I didn’t want to be the first.
If you’re in the area of Charley’s and have nothing to do, fine. Try it.
But don’t go out of your way for it. People hype it up, but it’s nothing special. If you’ve had an Arby’s sandwhich then you have at least a general idea of what it’s going to taste like.
Personally I think that Rochester’s garbage plate is far more of a true “try this” than beef on weck.
Edit; I would also make it a point to have italian while in town. I’ve traveled the country and western NY has the best italian food. In fact, the best italian restaurant that i’ve ever eaten is in Irondequoit NY. It’s called Pasta Villa and I can’t stop visiting. It’s perfect every time. A lot of italians settled down in that town and it’s truly something special.
.