Einstein

You can give a pig 50 NFL seasons and it may run a bit faster but it’ll never learn how to fly.

Yes, if we’re talking about no defender interaction, then it probably is around four or five. But I consider a drop anything that hit your hands and should reasonably be caught. I really don’t care if it defender hits your hands. That’s his job. Your job as an NFL player is to catch the ball regardless of what the defender is doing. so unless you’re interfered with… if that ball hit your hands, you better catch it. I had hope after that Seattle game. But that hope quickly diminished. so you’re saying, we drafted a small, non-physical WR that is also slow and can’t seperate!?

No, he had far more than that. Youre quoting drop statistics, which is not an official NFL stat and is therefore almost impossible to accurately track. Sites try, but the number is often wrong because there is no consensus on what is considered a drop. In reality he had close to double that if you actually watch the games.

Never. This is a very new thing for this regime. He didn’t even start criticizing Elam until this year (Elams 3rd full season).

That may be true, but he still looked like crap for much of the first half of the season too. He had that amazing catch vs Seattle but he also had numerous games of dropped balls, poor adjustments and no separation.

I think it was worth the swing. Rather try and fail than not try at all.

Von is a perfect example of a player Beane should have traded for but refused to give us the required capital to make it happen. Instead he was traded to LA and won a Super Bowl. I firmly believe we win the Super Bowl in 2021 if Beane made the Von trade. We needed just ONE stop against Mahomes that year and Von was still elite at that time. But Beane didn’t want to give up the 2nd round pick so instead we watched the Super Bowl from home.

Put another way: Would you trade Dalton Kincaid and Kaiir Elam for Myles Garrett? Those are our last 2 first round picks. If you wouldn't, then you're saying you have faith that Beane will suddenly make better first round choices.

Yeah that would suck.

Thats the best picture they could find?

That was beautiful.

Myopic view in my opinion. Offense scored 29 points this year, and would have had 27 point last year if Bass didn't shank the kick. Scoring 29 points wins you most playoff games. Giving up 27+ points loses you most playoff games. Having the ball last doesn't change that.

This.

Meanwhile we have Dorsey, err I mean Brady, running the same plays in the same situation that we have run all year, in the AFCCG. I especially enjoyed watching him run the same QB sneak over and over and over again that KC was stuffing. And running the same 4th down mesh play all year.

Smoke and mirrors, and I mean it. Those defenses were very good in the regular season and AWFUL in the playoffs. Again, smoke and mirrors. In those 9 other playoff games that were not against KC, we played Blake Bortles, Skyler Thompson, Mac Jones, Mason Rudolph, Rookie Bo Nix, Playoff Lamar, etc. The only great QB we played in those 9 other games was Joe Burrow and we gave up 27 points. We have had one of the easiest stretches of wildcard play in history.

You won’t find a bigger Josh Allen fan than me.

This I can agree with. At some point his physical freak-ness will begin to wane and he will win with his mind. We really do need to take advantage of the next 5 years.

This false narrative needs to go. It was only supposed to be a “learning” year for the media. That’s it. No one inside the organization had any goal other than Super Bowl.

Carter was a healthy scratch down the stretch. He came off the injury report on December 8th and then was made inactive 4 of the last 6 games. And in a 5th game he never made it onto the field.

2021: Taking Boogie Basham over Creed Humphrey was an all time screw up. 2022: Took Elam. Allowed KC to jump in front of us and take All-Pro McDuffie. Pro Bowl Tackle Tyler Smith went one pick after Elam. Pro Bowl (and one of the best int the NFL) Center Tyler Lindenbaum went 2 picks after Elam. 2023: Took Kincaid. Defensive rookie of the year finalist Joey Porter Jr went after. Offensive rookie of the year finalist LaPorta went after him too. To be fair, Porter had an up-and-down second year too.

Beane and McD had fairly critical tones of Coleman in the postseason press conference. I don’t think they’re too happy with him.

That’s genuinely shocking to me. I like Beane as a human being but having a GM who has never actually scouted players has to be a handicap. No wonder we whiff on so many early picks, and give our arch-nemesis the players they want.

I for one never knew that Beane was never a scout. That’s pretty eye-opening to me.

This is a real phenomena.