JohnNord

I’d rather have Josh Palmer and a rookie WR

Gee… I wonder what the difference was? He only played half a season with the Rams and never was injured. It happened years ago in Denver. Just because someone tears an ACL years ago doesn’t mean it’s guaranteed to happen again. You are correct though. Every big signing is one ACL from going sideways. That happened with Von. It doesn’t mean it was a bad move.

Recency bias. If you go back to the first season Von was in Buffalo, he was really good. 8 sacks in less than 12 games. Once he was injured the defensive pressure rate took a dump. In the end, he largely turned out to be bust but I’ll argue this was a swing worth taking. Exactly. Everyone saying that Von was injury prone due to the age is revisionist. Plenty of defenders have played at 30+ without tearing an ACL. All free agent signings are one bad injury from going awry. This was the case with Miller in Buffalo

I disagree… the Diggs trade definitely worked out. Josh turned into an elite QB and Diggs became a top 5 WR in the NFL. Also the Bills haven’t lost an AFCE Championship since his arrival. The re-signing of Diggs is the deal that killed the team. I think Beane might have moved too quickly thinking it might make him happier. Regardless, the initial risk was definitely worth the reward

Who is a “warm weather” team that is also a contender? Miami? San Fran? LAC? Basically he’s gonna Myles Garrett and sign with whoever pays him the most.

He was the worst player on defense in the Baltimore game and a big reason why Lamar sliced right through the defense. I don’t think he’s ready but we’ll see

It’s true 90% of the time. The difference is that Garrett has already earned over $120M in his NFL career. You’d think a veteran like Garrett might trade a couple millions if it meant winning a Lombardi Hendrickson is the only difference maker but he won’t get the contract he wants at 36.

The Garrett situation is a bit different. Watt and Hopkins said “I want to win a Super Bowl and my team isn’t serious about winning.” They actually left for OTHER teams. Garrett said the same thing about winning SB’s, also specified that it wasn’t about money for him and said he took his time making the decision, only to re-sign for money! It was probably a wise business decision for Garrett but a bad one for his legacy and also one that makes him look like a hypocrite. Oh well, when the Browns are in the basement of the AFC, at least Garrett can roll around in money pile

I have no problem with a player like Garrett taking the contract but it makes him look like a hypocrite when he asked for trade and said it’s about winning a Super Bowl and not about money. He ain’t winning ***** in Cleveland over the next few season. It’s ALL about the money. He looks like a huge hypocrite

Bills fans forget how good he was in 2022. He likely would have finished with double digit sacks Except Solomon isn’t as good

It’s easy to look at the result of Von’s career in Buffalo and say this move was a bust - but the process was solid. It all fell apart when he blew his ACL. When Von was active before Thanksgiving 2022, the defense was getting home with 4 and looked great. If you’re someone who wants a Trey Henrickson this season, you can’t criticize this move. No you don’t - go watch the last Baltimore TD drive. You don’t want Solomon getting those reps

Of course, but when he came back he didn’t look overly impressive

I did not think Brown did anything overly impressive since returning this season. He was fine but didn’t look like an $11M WR. Maybe it was injury related?

I haven’t watched a ton of Staley but he doesn’t seem to be as dominant as some of the better tackles in the NFL - including a player like Dion Dawkins.

I think the chances to get Garrett, Hendrickson, or Sweat were slim from to start. Now with the Rosseau on the books, there’s less money available down the line for their contracts. I think a more ideal move is acquiring a mid-level DE like a Landry or Mack and then to improve the DL. I wouldn’t mind the Reed move, I just see them signing a vet and drafting a rookie to compete at CB2

What impact player do you think they’ll sign? Because most of the DE’s will command upwards of $20 million per season and the new contracts kick in next season

I don’t disagree at all. I’m just trying to guess what will happen based on Beane’s past practices to roster building. I think Mack or Landry could be a possibility, and yes they would help, but those guys are not level that a Garrett or Hendrickson are at. I don’t see them being the difference makers that Beane and McDermott spoke of. That’s my concern. Rosseau has been consistently solid overall and excellent against the run. I think that continues but I just don’t see him taking that big of a step forward as a pass rusher. Maybe upgrading the middle of the DL unlocks him?

Right but when has Beane had 2 players in a position group making Top 5 and Top 20 money? I wouldn’t rule out adding another DE, I just don’t think it will be the names fans were hoping for like Garrett, Hendrickson, Sweat that would command a big deal

That’s not how Beane has typically managed the roster. I’d bet against Buffalo making a big move on defense but we’ll see

Right, it gives you money for this season but not beyond. Hendrickson or Sweat will want new contracts that will kick in at the same time Groot’s will. Hendrickson won’t facilitate a trade a team that isn’t prepared to give him a new. Myles Garrett won’t either It’s a lot of cap space to allocate to one position. I don’t see it happening but we will have to wait and see.

I can’t see them doing that…but we’ll see

How so? Let’s say that you sign Trey Hendrickson. He’s likely going to want a new 3-4 year deal before being traded. If you’re Buffalo will you allocate $40M+ on your two DE’s? Probably not. They’ll still add at EGDE I just don’t think it will be an impact player like we all had been hoping for.

I wasn’t crazy to see this deal because it likely means Buffalo isn’t coming away with a Myles Garrett type player. I like Rosseau, I just don’t think he’s ever going to be in the top tier of difference makers at DE. Beane is clearly banking on potential with this signing and reminds me a lot Ed Oliver a few years back.

Ok I missed that. My bad

It always seems like a Chiefs WR under Andy Reid finds themselves in legal trouble. Other than Tyreek, it’s not like Rice or Worthy had red flags.